|
IAALD
10th World Congress
Challenges facing the agricultural information community
in the third millennium
Dakar, Senegal, 24 to 28 January 2000
CONTRACT
MANAGEMENT: A NEW GOVERNMENT POLICY FOR OUTPUT FINANCING OF PRODUCTS AND
SERVICES
VAN
HARTEVELT, HANS
Royal Tropical Institute (KIT)
Abstract
During the last decades operations of KIT's Library depended largely on
government funding. In 1999, based on the new European regulations in
the field of subsidising, the Ministry decided on a new policy based on
contract management and output financing to fund products and services
instead of financing the activities. More emphasis had to be put on the
co-operation with institutes in developing countries and all the Library's
activities were to be placed in user and usage perspectives. In addition,
the Ministry introduced three objectives with regard to the Library's
operations: a) concentration on the identification of information projects
in developing countries; b) provision, in partnerships, of free access
to its holdings to organisations in developing countries; and c) supply
of information to development professionals in the Western world. The
success of the above objectives will depend on identifying partners wishing
to participate in the formulation of programmes, seeking of funding and
joint execution.
Keywords: Government
funding; Information services; Development assistance; Output financing;
Partnerships
GESTION CONTRACTUELLE
: UNE NOUVELLE POLITIQUE DU GOUVERNEMENT POUR LE FINANCEMENT DES RESULTATS
OBTENUS, PLUS PARTICULIEREMENT LE FINANCEMENT DES PRODUITS ET DES SERVICE
Résumé
Au cours des dernieres décades, le travail de la Bibliotheque du
KIT dépendait largement de la subvention par le Gouvernement. Selon
les nouveaux reglements européens dans le domaine des subventions,
le Ministere a adopté une nouvelle politique de gestion contractuelle
ainsi qu'une nouvelle politique de financement des résultats obtenus
dans le but de financer les produits et les services au lieu de financer
les activités. Il a fallu mettre plus d'accent sur la coopération
avec des instituts dans les pays en voie de développement et placer
toutes les activités de la Bibliotheque dans le cadre des perspectives
de l'utilisateur et de l'utilisation. De plus, le Ministere a introduit
trois objectifs en ce qui concerne le travail de la Bibliotheque : a)
se concentrer sur l'identification de projets d'information ; b) en collaboration
avec les partenaires, donner un acces libre a ses collections, aux organisations
dans les pays en voie de développement, c) fournir de l'information
aux spécialistes en développement a l'Occident. Le succes
des objectifs cités ci-dessus dépendra de l'identification
des partenaires qui veulent participer a la formulation des programmes,
chercher des financements et exécution concourant.
Mots clé
: Financement par le Gouvernement ; Services d'information ; Assistance
au développement ; Financement des résultats obtenus ; Partenariat
1 Introduction
The history of the Library of the Royal Tropical Institute (Koninklijk
Instituut voor de Tropen) dates back to 1777. Since then the Library has
undergone several changes and has been governed by various bodies. The
mission, however, has always remained the same: to gather and disseminate
knowledge of overseas regions, beginning with the former colonies
and evolving into the tropics. Since 1910 (the official establishment
of KIT) many library collections from private and public organisations
have been handed over to KIT and have been merged into its own vast holdings
which to date include some 250,000 books, 15,000 journals and 25,000 maps,
all pertaining to the tropics. In addition KIT holds some 200,000 documents,
in the form of brochures, unique manuscripts, newspapers and monographs,
which belong to the national Dutch cultural heritage.
Today, the Library, employing a total staff of 60, is an independent department
which comprises the Documentation, the Map Collection and the 'commercial'
information management unit which has implemented projects in over 50
different countries in Africa, Asia, Latin America and the former Soviet
Union republics. The annual budget totals e4 million which comes from
the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. In addition to this the Library generates
additional revenue to the tune of e300,000 - e500,000 from the market
sector by implementing projects and raising funds through sponsorships.
In the 1950s, the KIT-Library broadened its scope by publishing its abstracting
journal in English instead of Dutch. TROPAG, in its different formats,
found its way to libraries all over the world. The only changes in policy
were based on the ever developing information technology. The abstracts
which were issued in printed form since 1953 were made available in electronic
format as an online database accessible through telecommunication facilities
in 1975 and on CD-ROM in 1988. Apart from the ICT revolution, the Library
also had to face the financial consequences of an economic crises which
lead to Government cutbacks. This forced the Library to generate alternative
funds in order to cover its ever increasing costs.
2. New policy
In 1999, the year the Euro was officially introduced in Europe, the Government
of the Netherlands changed its policy towards funding of organisations
such as KIT. In anticipation of the economic and financial integration
of the European Union, and the new EU regulations in the field of subsidising,
the Government decided to discontinue its existing relationship with KIT
and to replace it by a new agreement, based on contract management. The
new agreement had to be discussed in the framework of output financing,
and funding of products and services instead of subsidising activities.
The Institute was divided and decentralised into several modules such
as Museum, Theatre, Agricultural Development, and Library. For each module
products and services had to be defined in terms of output and made comparable
with similar products and services rendered by other organisations not
only in the Netherlands but also in the member states of the European
Union. External auditing bureaux reviewed the products and services in
terms of efficiency and costs in order to establish pricing standards
for output. This was followed by a process of negotiations between the
module managers and the relevant management of the Ministry of Foreign
Affairs. A transition period for the implementation of the contract was
eventually fixed at three years.
For the Library traditional activities such as acquisition, cataloguing,
indexing, abstracting, documentation, database management, automation,
loan services and lending, shelving, current awareness, etc. were no longer
accepted as activities for direct subsidy. All the activities had to be
placed in user and usage perspective and were transformed into products
and services. The number of information sources and its management were
no longer accepted as indicators. The number of users had to be defined
and indicated on a quarterly basis. The same applies to the items catalogued;
these were no longer relevant, only the number of records retrieved were
fundable. Funding will now be made available based on statistics given
in reports which have to be submitted quarterly.
If the targets are not met, funding will be withheld, despite ongoing
fixed costs for personnel and acquisitions. Not only quantity is important,
in addition the Library also has to assess the quality. User appreciation
has to be measured, as does the most frequent and less frequently retrieved
items.
The risks are of course enormous. Not only financially speaking if and
when targets are not met, but also in terms of collection building, since
the collection (quality and its entirety) is no longer subject to review,
but to the following of fashions and trends.
3. Strategy
In general the Ministry argued that available funds had to be used partly
to initiate partnerships with institutions in overseas countries, rather
than in the Netherlands alone. The justification of the Library's existence
had to be found in its co-operative programmes the developing world. To
realise this and to maintain the facilities on which the products and
services had to be based at an acceptable level, three basic strategies
were formulated.
3.1 Institutional
Partnerships
Ever since its existence, the Library was equipped to render its services
not only to users in the tropics but also to researchers, development
workers and students in the Netherlands visiting the Library. Now the
Ministry had decided that researchers and students are no longer the target
audience of the Library and as such can only be served marginally. The
visiting hours of the Library for this group of users therefore have to
be limited in favour of the identification of institutional partners for
final co-operation.
3.2 Co-ordination and co-operation with libraries and information services
in The Netherlands
The funds for collection development will eventually decrease, partly
because the Ministry will not provide any additional funds for price compensation
and partly because more money will have to be allocated to products and
services to be launched in the developing world. In order to keep the
coverage of professional literature at an acceptable level, KIT has to
identify Dutch partners with whom an agreement can be made for the co-ordination
of collection policy and also to generate additional income.
3.3 Synergy
In the design of its products, such as pathfinders, internet publications,
and information services, the Library has to study the possibilities of
achieving more synergy between the various actors involved in the development
process both in the Western and Southern world.
4. Objectives
Following the above mission and strategy an agreement was finally reached
to meet three objectives to be realised during the contract period of
four years.
4.1 Technical Co-operation
In addition to its market activities, the Library has to contribute to
the establishment of information services strengthening organisations
involved in agricultural and rural development. The main focus of this
contribution will be identification and formulation of information projects
together with partners in the developing world. Ultimately, financially
viable proposals have to be submitted to donor agencies for funding of
the formulated projects. The total number of projects has been fixed at
8-12 per year.
The following criteria
in order to accept proposals submitted have been developed:
- In general the projects may not compete with those in the 'market'.
- The funds have to be used in the developing world, excluding conferences,
courses, publications, etc. in the western world. Projects requiring open-ended
funding will not be considered.
- Projects have to fall within the overall framework of agricultural and
rural development.
- Target audiences consist of organisations involved in the development
process such as policy-makers, development workers, researchers, extension
workers and information intermediaries.
Furthermore, the following indicators for success will be used: sustainability,
involvement of the counterpart through (small) contributions, accountability;
fundability, regional function, measurable objectives.
One of the projects which was clearly agreed upon is the so-called international
co-operation to produce the TROPAG database. To date, two partners have
been identified in China and India and additional partners are being sought
in Africa and Latin America. In short, KIT provides facilities (equipment
and courses) to enable the partners to contribute to the TROPAG database
for which KIT pays a fee. The ultimate objective of this project is to
investigate the feasibility of transferring the entire production of the
agricultural database to the partners involved or parties interested.
4.2 Information supply
to specific target audiences in developing countries
Based on the information sources available in Amsterdam, products, such
as the TROPAG database, newsletters and the publication Gender, Development
and Society have to be produced in order to provide access to the Library's
vast resources. Also traditional question and answer services and document
delivery services are provided. The costs involved in providing these
services are covered in the contract between the Ministry and KIT, with
the exception of the publications for which a subscription fee is still
required.
In addition the Library has to identify 5-6 partner organisations in the
developing world in order to support an information flow between KIT and
the partners overseas, also comprising the above services which will be
funded by the Ministry.
4.3 Information supply
to development professionals and information intermediaries in western
countries.
Question and answer services as well as document delivery services can
be provided at no charge to organisations involved in development work.
In conclusion, although
the new policy is a challenge for the future a balance has to be found
between implementation and the continued existence of a precious collection
of 250,000 books, 15,000 journals, 25,000 maps and approximately 200,000
documents belonging to the Dutch cultural heritage all pertaining to the
developing region which has been gathered over centuries.
The above policy and objectives have to be realised during the contract
period which will be reviewed for extension in December 2002. Partners
wishing to participate in the implementation are invited to contact the
Royal Tropical Institute.
|